Welcome to the Invelos forums. Please read the forum rules before posting.

Read access to our public forums is open to everyone. To post messages, a free registration is required.

If you have an Invelos account, sign in to post.

    Invelos Forums->DVD Profiler: Contribution Discussion Page: 1 2  Previous   Next
Disambiguating minor actors
Author Message
DVD Profiler Desktop and Mobile Registrantwintermute115
What Would Batman Do?
Registered: May 25, 2007
United States Posts: 176
Posted:
PM this userVisit this user's homepageView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
Where there are two minor actors with the same name*, who don't have personal websites, entries in Wikipedia or other reliable sources that can be tracked down, and whose birth years can only be found on IMDb, how should they be disambiguated?

Should we pretend that they are the same person, or would IMDb be a sufficiently source to point out that they are different people? I suspect that the latter case would be preferable, but a consensus ruling would be helpful. Thanks.

*In this case, I'm thinking of:
John Nolan and
John Nolan
 Last edited: by wintermute115
DVD Profiler Unlimited RegistrantStar ContributorAddicted2DVD
Registered: March 13, 2007
Reputation: Highest Rating
United States Posts: 17,334
Posted:
PM this userEmail this userView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
Well as I said in our PMs I can only go by the rules and Ken Statements. Which was Not to use a 3rd party database... and in a case like this (adding Birth year/role names) Ken said we could use imdb... but not as a sole source.. you must have other sources to go with it.

So with the above in mind I had to vote no... from here I would say it is up to Ken and Gerri if you can't find any other sources.
Pete
DVD Profiler Unlimited RegistrantStar ContributorWinston Smith
Don't be discommodious
Registered: March 13, 2007
United States Posts: 21,610
Posted:
PM this userEmail this userView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
I agree in principle with Pete. However I will also say there is a difference between copying IMDb data andusing them as a reference source, but at the same time I don't trust their data, so there is no way I would cite them as a sole source. I would keep digging, the answer (a second source) is out there...somewhere.

Skip
ASSUME NOTHING!!!!!!
CBE, MBE, MoA and proud of it.
Outta here

Billy Video
DVD Profiler Unlimited RegistrantStar ContributorAddicted2DVD
Registered: March 13, 2007
Reputation: Highest Rating
United States Posts: 17,334
Posted:
PM this userEmail this userView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
and it being the sole source is the reason for the no vote.
Pete
DVD Profiler Unlimited RegistrantStar Contributornorthbloke
Registered: March 15, 2007
Reputation: High Rating
United Kingdom Posts: 5,459
Posted:
PM this userDirect link to this postReply with quote
I've got to agree with Pete's no vote.
IMDB is fine as one source as long as you can find another one to confirm it.
Remember you only need to confirm one birth year, as the other can be left blank if necessary.

Edit: the BFI database confirms the dob of the American John Nolan as 1933.
It doesn't list the UK John Nolan's dob unfortunately, but this should let you submit the US one at least and separate them.
 Last edited: by northbloke
DVD Profiler Desktop and Mobile Registrantwintermute115
What Would Batman Do?
Registered: May 25, 2007
United States Posts: 176
Posted:
PM this userVisit this user's homepageView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
OK, my thoughts are this:

1) Given two different actors with the same name, it's better to have them disambiguated than not.

2) Birth year is not primary data in DVD Pro, but is only used for disambiguation. Indeed, adding a birth year for any other reason is against the rules. Therefore, it shouldn't necessarily be held to such a high standard as the primary data.

3) If specific birth years can't be tracked down for either actor, then putting an unambiguous string in the birth year field (eg. "Quincy" in one of these cases - can the birthyear accept non-numeric data? Has anyone tried that?) would be preferable to leaving it blank. This also raises the issue of how actors with the same name and birth year should be handled; is there a consensus on that?

Given this, it makes sense to me that if the only available data for birth year comes from IMDb (and I have taken all reasonable steps to track down other sources), and that provides unambiguous and distinct data for both actors, that data should be used provisionally to disambiguate them. If sources are found at a future that invalidate these dates, then they should be used instead.

However, the consensus here seems to be that it would be preferable to pretend that these two actors are in fact the same person, rather than risk their birth dates not being exactly correct. If this is what the community wants to go with, I can accept that, but I have to say I think it's a very odd decision.
DVD Profiler Unlimited RegistrantStar ContributorAddicted2DVD
Registered: March 13, 2007
Reputation: Highest Rating
United States Posts: 17,334
Posted:
PM this userEmail this userView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
if you look above your post you will see someone else already found a second source for one of them... which shows it is not impossible. So update that one with the second source and you will be within the rules and Ken/Gerri's wishes.

It has nothing to do with what we prefer... and all to do with what the rules and what Ken/Gerri has said it must be.
Pete
DVD Profiler Desktop and Mobile Registrantwintermute115
What Would Batman Do?
Registered: May 25, 2007
United States Posts: 176
Posted:
PM this userVisit this user's homepageView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
Quoting northbloke:
Quote:
Edit: the BFI database confirms the dob of the American John Nolan as 1933.
It doesn't list the UK John Nolan's dob unfortunately, but this should let you submit the US one at least and separate them.


Unfortunately, that link doesn't include his credit for Quincy, ME (but comparing the list to his IMDb filmography makes it clear it's the same actor), which is where I submitted the disambiguation. Which means that I'm not sure it would count as sufficient source for the contribution I made. Any thoughts?
DVD Profiler Unlimited RegistrantStar ContributorAddicted2DVD
Registered: March 13, 2007
Reputation: Highest Rating
United States Posts: 17,334
Posted:
PM this userEmail this userView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
I haven't looked at it till now... it doesn't list his filmography... not sure what to say there. I would be open to opinion on it.
Pete
DVD Profiler Desktop and Mobile Registrantwintermute115
What Would Batman Do?
Registered: May 25, 2007
United States Posts: 176
Posted:
PM this userVisit this user's homepageView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
Quoting Addicted2DVD:
Quote:
I haven't looked at it till now... it doesn't list his filmography... not sure what to say there. I would be open to opinion on it.


Did you try clicking on the Flimography link?
DVD Profiler Unlimited RegistrantStar Contributornorthbloke
Registered: March 15, 2007
Reputation: High Rating
United Kingdom Posts: 5,459
Posted:
PM this userDirect link to this postReply with quote
There's also this page, which includes a picture of the actor, but I'm not as familiar with this site so can't confirm it's reliability.
 Last edited: by northbloke
DVD Profiler Unlimited RegistrantStar ContributorWinston Smith
Don't be discommodious
Registered: March 13, 2007
United States Posts: 21,610
Posted:
PM this userEmail this userView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
Winter:

Since I have yet to begin work on BY and Common Names, I can only say that I am aware of the possibility of two actors for which wew cannot obtain BY data. How pervasive this might be I probably won't know for awhile. The last time this came up it was suggested that, in such hopefully, relatively unusual an event, we could perhaps use the Year of a person's first credited appearance, this would seem to be more easily obtainable piece of information.

But you only need the BY data for ONE of the John Nolan's, both are unnecessary...unlessa thiord is uncovered.

Skip
ASSUME NOTHING!!!!!!
CBE, MBE, MoA and proud of it.
Outta here

Billy Video
DVD Profiler Desktop and Mobile Registrantwintermute115
What Would Batman Do?
Registered: May 25, 2007
United States Posts: 176
Posted:
PM this userVisit this user's homepageView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
I've added the two links to the contribution notes, so hopefully this will help. Thanks for managing to track these down.
DVD Profiler Unlimited RegistrantStar ContributorAddicted2DVD
Registered: March 13, 2007
Reputation: Highest Rating
United States Posts: 17,334
Posted:
PM this userEmail this userView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
Quoting wintermute115:
Quote:
Quoting Addicted2DVD:
Quote:
I haven't looked at it till now... it doesn't list his filmography... not sure what to say there. I would be open to opinion on it.


Did you try clicking on the Flimography link?


actually I diidn't... missed it.. thanks
Pete
DVD Profiler Unlimited RegistrantStar Contributortweeter
I aim to misbehave
Registered: June 12, 2007
Reputation: High Rating
United States Posts: 2,665
Posted:
PM this userView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
Quoting wintermute115:
Quote:
I've added the two links to the contribution notes, so hopefully this will help. Thanks for managing to track these down.

Saw this thread only after adding my No vote.  The notes are updated but i see no links in them.
Bad movie?  You're soaking in it!
DVD Profiler Unlimited RegistrantStar Contributormdnitoil
Registered: March 14, 2007
United States Posts: 1,777
Posted:
PM this userView this user's DVD collectionDirect link to this postReply with quote
I think as a general principle, the point about which is more important, differentiating actors or getting dead solid birth years, is still a valid question.  Personally, I could care less if the birth years are correct.  I'd gladly suffer some incorrect birth years if it meant getting the proper actors credited for their work.  Of course that's just my opinion.  It will come up more often as people start to get serious about this and dig into the golden age films.  I've been working on my database for a while and information on many of these older contract players is hard to come by.  That and their name variations over the course of their careers.
    Invelos Forums->DVD Profiler: Contribution Discussion Page: 1 2  Previous   Next