Quote:
Skip.

I seem to recall Ken stating that a re-release cna have previous uncredited as long as it is documented that it came form the database. I voted no because I thought he said he was including cover scans and I didn't see them, that was my bad for not understading his notes.

As for being insulting, to some, the word Kiddo would be an insult.

Quote:
Then sir if you submitted the cover art for the UPCs in question why didn't YOU update the information to go along with it? Being a database administrator professionally you never input incomplete or missing data. To keep the peace I will withdraw the information, but in the future I suggest that when voting on submissions you clearly specify and completely include all reasons why you vote no. End of discussion you will hear no more from me on this.

Quote:
Quoting 8ballMax:

Quote:
oops...sorry...wrong thread.  Thought the title was Submissives.

You are a bad bad boy!  
"No dessert for you" - Nurse Diesel

(I picked the wrong Cloris Leachman role - I think I have it right now! If not, no dessert for me either!)

Quote:
Erik:

What Ken said was that (uncredited) can be removed IF it is an obvious clone of a certain Db. And I have said i won't do that, I will try and modify such , to make the connection less obvious. But that is another discussion, in another thread.

Skip

Quote:
Quoting pplchamp:

Quote:
Skip.

I seem to recall Ken stating that a re-release cna have previous uncredited as long as it is documented that it came form the database. I voted no because I thought he said he was including cover scans and I didn't see them, that was my bad for not understading his notes.

As for being insulting, to some, the word Kiddo would be an insult.

Actually, I recall the same thing, that if you are replicating an exiting profile (as for another locality) that all you have to do is document that that's where the uncredited cast came from.

Quote:
Here is what ken said.

"I'll reiterate it here - if the source of the data is not immediately evident, there's no reason to remove uncredited entries.  However, if (for instance), the data is a carbon copy of IMDB or any other third party database, that is enough reason to remove it.  When removing it, be specific in your contribution notes so we don't pass it over."

There is nothing to support your memory Hal or Erik's.

This touched off a firestorm of concern over whether or not (uncredited) would start being summarily removed.

Skip

Quote:
Copying cast and crew entries from another entries is permissable.  Just list that as your source.  You should try to verify that the version of the film is the same before the copy, and be sure to check the contribution notes of the source profile.

Quote:

Not in that quote, but he also said:
Quoting Ken Cole:

Quote:
Copying cast and crew entries from another entries is permissable.  Just list that as your source.  You should try to verify that the version of the film is the same before the copy, and be sure to check the contribution notes of the source profile.

Quote:
"...and be sure to check the contribution notes of the source profile."

I think that is an important point. If there is no documentation in the contribution notes for the data source, then a wholesale copy should be re-verified.