Quote:
Yes. As long as you still have 2.4 or 2.5 installed and have that title in your collection. The notes are still there.

Quote:
Here Dan

Quote:
Posted: May 26, 2007 8:38 PM
PM this user Email this user Visit this user's homepage View this user's DVD collection Edit post Reply with quote
I'll reiterate it here - if the source of the data is not immediately evident, there's no reason to remove uncredited entries.  However, if (for instance), tarhe data is a carbon copy of IMDB or any other third party database, that is enough reason to remove it.  When removing it, be specific in your contribution notes so we don't pass it over.

Quote:
Posted: May 26, 2007 9:16 PM
PM this user Email this user Visit this user's homepage View this user's DVD collection Edit post Reply with quote
Yes, if they are clearly exact copies, they should be removed before resubmitting.

The above are Ken's most recent quotes on the topic.

Skip

Quote:

No, we're not asking for plausible denaiability.  What we need to avoid is accepting contributions which are a copy of the IMDB data, or of any third party database.  There's a difference between checking a few roles by researching from various sites, and visiting a single third party source, making a carbon copy of their data.

Quote:
Contributions which contain unmodified prior uncredited entries are not required to state the source of those uncredited entries.  Only if you are adding new uncredited entries (or indeed any new cast/crew), is a source needed.

If you believe the uncredited entries are a carbon copy of a third party source, and the existing contribution note history doesn't supply a source, you may remove them, but are not required to do so.

Quote:
Which means that if other users disagree with that belief they are free to vote NO.

Skip

Quote:
Quoting Rifter:

Quote:
I will tell you this, though, if people start jumping my case for legitimate removals there will be hell to pay, because I'll start looking for the least little thing to jump on.

Now there's a very ADULT attitude.

Quote:
Yeah, it's just as adult as the comment about people voting no because it was my opinion they should be removed, because after all - I don't have any right to that opinion.

Quote:
Quoting kdh1949:

Quote:
Quoting Rifter:

Quote:
Yeah, it's just as adult as the comment about people voting no because it was my opinion they should be removed, because after all - I don't have any right to that opinion.

No, it isn't as adult as the comment you mention.  What is childish is threating retribution because of this relatively minor disagreement.

Then what do you call this?  If this isn't a thinly veiled threat of future dealings, I don't know what is:

"If we followed your thinking, almost all uncredited cast would have to be removed. I know, that's what you want. But that isn't what we want and you are in a very small minority on this subject. If you want to begin removing all "uncredited" cast from the db you might have chosen a less obvious release. All you have succeeded in doing is exposing your desire to remove all uncredited cast to more people and more will be watching for this from you."

Not only is the premise of that statement wrong, but I have said repeatedly that it's wrong, but I find people already voting on contributions based on that belief.  And you call ME childish?  Get a grip.

Quote:
Then what do you call this?  If this isn't a thinly veiled threat of future dealings, I don't know what is:

"If we followed your thinking, almost all uncredited cast would have to be removed. I know, that's what you want. But that isn't what we want and you are in a very small minority on this subject. If you want to begin removing all "uncredited" cast from the db you might have chosen a less obvious release. All you have succeeded in doing is exposing your desire to remove all uncredited cast to more people and more will be watching for this from you."

Not only is the premise of that statement wrong, but I have said repeatedly that it's wrong, but I find people already voting on contributions based on that belief.  And you call ME childish?  Get a grip.